Question: In a recent Sanga, ‘Sat gurus and siksa mantras,’ you wrote that “women are not more lusty than men nor less intelligent.” This appears to me to be quite contradictory to what Srila Prabhupada said about the subject. Can a ‘sat guru’ answer this question?

Answer: Srila Prabhupada has said that women are less intelligent and more lusty than men. It appears that I have said something different. However, what Prabhupada said about women is subject to time, circumstance, information available, and interpretation. If statements like ‘women are less intelligent than men’ are to be taken as absolute, then no woman at any time could be more intelligent than any man. Is that true? You are a man. Ask yourself if this is true and answer honestly. Are you more intelligent than every woman on Earth? Is every woman on Earth more lusty than you?

If not, then you have to interpret Prabhupada’s words to fit with your own experience and with what you know to be true. You have to consider what Prabhupada meant by intelligence, who he was talking to, and whether what he said is to be considered siddhanta (absolute conclusion) or a cultural consideration relative to times past when women were uneducated, etc., etc. This is what I have done in dealing with this subject.

Can your question be answered? I think so, but you should know that yours is not a spiritual question, neither in substance nor in form. It has nothing to do with spiritual life proper, and its tenor is not concerned with understanding the truth, but rather with showcasing your own knowledge. Unfortunately, here you have only demonstrated your foolishness.

email

Newsletter

Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter digest.

*Your email will always remain confidential.

Comment Policy

ISKCON.Us encourages civil, engaged conversation. Our moderators have broad discretion to remove comments that violate our policy.
  • https://www.facebook.com/jeremy.adkison Jeremy Adkison

    Swamiji nailed it. \O/

    Glories to Srila Prabhupada and Swami Tripurari!

  • http://gravatar.com/markandeyadasa Bhakta Marcos

    One aspect of Swami B.V. Tripurāri’s answers I admire the most is that they are often short and chock full of deep meaning with multifaceted ramifications that helps one think about certain things in a different manner. This is one of those answers. To assume everything fits between our time and circumstance does not allow for a live parampara that can accommodate for bhakti anyone. Thank you.

  • Jagadish

    Ditto the above comments. Very powerful answer and succinct.

  • BB dasa

    Is it really so brilliant and succinct to tell the person asking a sincere question that he is demonstrating his foolishness? I find it rather unnecessary.
    As to the question to whom Srila Prabhupada made his comments about women’s intelligence: It’s in his books, so his comments were meant for a rather large audience, not just to one person or two. As to the argument itself: if it is so obvious today that there are women who are more intelligent than men, then I guess that information was available in the 1970ies, too.
    And last not least, trying to understand what your spiritual master said and why – is not spiritual? What, then, is?

  • satyavati devi dasi

    I love His Holiness Swami Tripurari. All glories to his preachings. His wise advices are always full of compassion and understanding. I would wish that every Swami in ISKCON would have the same viewpoint toward this topic. Thank you very much. Hare Krishna!

  • Srinjaya

    The following two articles by Sriman Hari Sauri Prabhu provide an in-depth and rigorous treatment of the subject and is congruent with our siddhanta:

    “Srila Prabhupada said that women are less-intelligent than men. Can we support this?”

    http://akincana.net/philosophy/262-srila-prabhupada-said-that-women-are-less-intelligent-than-men-can-we-support-this.html

    and

    “A response to Hari-kirtana prabhu regarding my article”

    http://akincana.net/philosophy/263-a-response-to-hari-kirtana-prabhu-regarding-my-article.html

    • Sri Radha Paramasundari dd

      Thank you so much for the links to those two great articles by Hari Sauri Prabhu. Very deep and full of knowledge and respect for the person who asked the question. Much more satisfying and enlightening than Tripurari’s flippant retort that ends up with a put down for the person who asked. He should have just said he really didn’t know the answer. We need enlightenment not someone trying to show how much they (don’t) know.